Are We Overly Critical of Anime?

The anime community is one of the best around when you’re looking for devoted fellow otaku who want to share opinions and thoughts with others. That being said, the anime community has always been quick to divulge their ideals, thoughts, and opinions to anyone who opposes their own. Like many modern-day communities, the anime community—which we consider ourselves a part of here at Honey’s Anime—can get truly fired up when anime is the focus…almost too an extreme level. That poses the question. Are anime fans too critical of a medium we all love?

Defend Your Series!!!

No one will argue that human beings defend themselves when they are faced with an opposing force either physically or mentally. Our nature as otaku is just that, to defend our love for everything Japan even if seems a little excessive. Is that love for the medium or are we just being overly critical? Let’s think about it using the power of examples.

When Attack on Titan: Final Season began airing recently, fans immediately began imposing their thoughts into the pool of forums online. We saw people rage about a new studio taking control—in this case, Wit Studio gave Attack on Titan to MAPPA—and had opinions on the animation before episode 1 even aired. The Promised Neverland faced some online backlash as well with fans arguing that content was cut from the manga source material and were adamant that this would be a reason this season failed. Yes, these issues are worrisome but here’s why we fellow otaku need to relax and calm down just a smidge.

Anime developers like MAPPA are studios well known for their excellence in anime production. MAPPA has crafted works like Terror in Resonance, Kids on the Slope, Yuri!!! on Ice and Kakegurui to name a few famous series. They know what they're doing and it's why we need to trust that they can handle a famous series like Attack on Titan with the same love we have. Basically, we need to have faith in the anime studios that have delivered works to us that we all loved and felt were truly master-crafts in the anime world.

Episode 1 Was Bad…Rate the Show 1/10

Recent series Ex-Arm’s first episode proved to be quite terrible if we’re holding back our disdain a bit. That being said, anime viewers wasted no time in going to sites like MAL and rating the series 2.5/10 as if the entire series was done from the opening gate. We here at Honey’s Anime expressed our…disliking of Ex-Arm but we were sure to say one thing anime fans tend to forget. It was only the first episode!

A common anime viewing practice is to watch three episodes of a series before judging if they will continue watching the show weekly or move on/drop the anime series. While this “rule” has its own issues—what if a show goes on for more than 12 episodes—it allows a good means to avoid overanalyzing a show before anything has actually happened. Ignoring this simple rule and right away reviewing a series before episode 2 is a prime example of anime fans raging a bit too hard without giving a show a chance to redeem itself. Though in all fairness, Ex-Arm has a lot of redeeming if it wishes to save itself from a truly disastrous first episode.

Having Different Opinions Doesn’t Mean Hating Opinions

Obviously, anime is like music, art, and various other mediums. One person might love Sword Art Online and Log Horizon while another may utterly hate hearing those words put together. That is just how we are as otaku, we have unique tastes in anime. Anime is a medium that ranges from horror like Higurashi: When They Cry- New to harem fantasy like The Hidden Dungeon Only I Can Enter. Anime is wacky, series, melancholy, and a million other emotions and that is why we need to really learn the most forgotten word of this current generation…respect.

Anime fans come in all flavors from old to young and from male to female. That is the beauty of Japan’s gift to us otaku. We are all different and it makes our tastes different which is why our passions also differ so immensely! There needs to be a time where the anime community realizes that just because we have different opinions from each other doesn’t mean those opinions are filled with negativity or hate. In the end, we all love what we love and that just makes us different in beautiful ways!

Final Thoughts

Decades ago before the internet, there was no anime community. Anime fans were scattered like the world’s various countries. Now in 2021, the anime community has become its own metropolis filled with amazing people who truly are testaments to how big anime has become. That is why we anime fans need to stop being so critical of anime and realize anime—even when it's bad—was created by someone who loved anime just like us. Studios new and old are filled with fellow otaku who only wish to show their love for all things anime like we do and one day give us the next big anime series!

What do you fellow readers think? Do we need to stop hating on anime so much and overanalyzing every scene? Let us know your thoughts in the comments down below! For even more anime-related articles likes this one keep stuck to our never jaded hive here at Honey’s Anime!

Shingeki-no-kyojin-Wallpaper-5-500x281 Are We Overly Critical of Anime?


Author: Aaron

Hey everyone I’m Aaron Curbelo or Blade as I’m called by my YouTube Subscribers. I’ve been an anime/manga fan since I was a young kid. In terms of anime I have watched nearly a thousand shows and have read hundreds of manga series. I love writing and honestly was so happy to join Honey’s Anime to get a shot to write articles for such a wonderful site. I’m a firm believer in respect in the anime community being the most important embodiment we should all have. We all love anime and we have varying opinions of series but we should respect one another for those differences! Life is too precious to spend it making needless arguments in a community that should be the shining example of loving an amazing medium. I hope as a writer for Honey’s Anime I can bring you folks some amazing articles to read and enjoy!

Previous Articles

Top 5 Anime by Aaron